You Are Here: Home » Linux » Opinion

Why Unity Will Become The Best Thing That Has Ever Happened To Ubuntu

By on July 4th, 2011     

It has been two full months since Ubuntu 11.04 “Natty Narwhal” was released with the new Unity user interface. With Unity, Canonical has taken a very drastic step and cut down on a lot of customizability that many power users would want. Understandably, many proclaimed that Unity is the best thing that Canonical has ever done. There was even an article claiming that Ubuntu is on a decline due to Unity.

About a month ago, I too believed that the decision to have Unity as the default user interface is the worst one Shuttleworth has ever taken in regards to Ubuntu. I hated the fact that the Unity launcher is so damn unconfigurable – there is no easy way to change the color or to change its position. I hated that the Unity panel no longer supports the applets. I did not like the AppMenu. I hate it so much because it sometimes goes unresponsive for no reason at all. And most of all, I really dislike Unity when I plugin my external monitor – it is not possible to have the launcher on both the screens and it is extremely difficult to use applications like Gimp because the menu bar on the AppMenu is so far away from the work area.

unity-dash

Unity Dash in Ubuntu 11.04

 

Now, though, my view on Unity is changing. I still do not like it but I can now appreciate the thoughts that went into the development of Unity. Although Unity in Ubuntu 11.04, has a lot of problems in the way it is implemented, I think that many elements (with the exception of the AppMenu) actually makes sense design wise. For example, the Dash makes much more sense than a menu – it is a much faster way to get to an application. Unity was never meant for power users who like to tweak everything about the system. It is meant for the normal users who just want a computer that looks good and works well.

I have gotten three people – two of them Mac users and a Windows user - to try out Ubuntu 11.04 in the last two weeks. All of them are just the average computer user who uses the computer to just browse the internet, listen to some song, watch a few movies etc. Interestingly, all three of them liked Unity. They simply did not care that they cannot change the launcher position or that they cannot add applets to the panel. To them, it works, the Unity dash is very easy to use and it looks clean and pretty.

I am not sure if they are still sticking with Ubuntu, but Ubuntu did make an impression on them and that is what Mark Shuttleworth is aiming for. He wants Ubuntu to impress the normal users and convert them to Ubuntu users. He himself has gone on record saying that he is aiming for 200 million Ubuntu users by 2015. Ubuntu is not going to get to that number by being attractive to the Linux power users and developers only. They need to get new users by converting Windows users and to a lesser extent Mac users – and Unity is Shuttlewoth’s best bet on doing that.




         Submit to Reddit     Stumble


Related Posts by Tags: ,



  • Pb21a

    I see your point but disagree. I took your header as a joke. I am saddened to find it was not.
    It was released before it was ready, despite the resounding commentary of many others.
    Unity is far from being ready for general use, and a bad experience of existing users can go a very long way… no more referrals from me, I now recommend Mint or Pinguy.
    Update Manger suggested an “upgrade”. I had trust in Ubuntu and just did it.  It lunched my system. I ended up formatting my partition and doing a fresh install.
    Even then it crashes and does weird things… I continue to play with it but it is nor taken seriously. The announcement that Classic Mode will no longer be available on 11.10 was the last straw.

    • http://digitizor.com/ Ricky Laishram

      I agree that Unity was released way before it is ready. But I believe that it will be much better by the time next LTS (Ubuntu 12.04) is released. I am of the opinion that if user wants stability, they should be looking at the LTS, not the 6 month release.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I32UYQJ2ZBOZ37UCAQPB56OVCE Luigi

      Since it was decided that Unity will be the default shell, there are two ways to approach it. Which one will offer the fastest pace of development?

      scenario 1: unity is NOT disclosed to the public and developed only internally until it reaches full maturity.
      scenario 2: unity is disclosed to the public and developed by the whole community.

      Check and mate.

  • http://techeverytime.com Ankur

    its good but I cannot say best 

  • Anonymous

    12.04 will change everything :)

  • Pingback: Links 5/7/2011: GNU/Linux Thrives in Germany, Brazil; More Android Tablets | Techrights

  • Jean Horten

    Tried to use 11.04 for 10 days, it was the worst, most unstable and buggy operating system I have ever tried and I was close to moving back to Micro$oft due to compiz crashes ( compiz 0.9 is stated as experimental, but was pushed through for unity nevertheless), system freezes in the middle of softwareupgrades, sound losses in certain applications after an upgrade of some libs a general slowness and irresponsibility of teh system and startup times of sometimes more than 2 minutes. Ubuntu 11.04 is not ready for prime time, it’s not even beta and I fear 11.10 based on Gnome 3 will be even worse. I am back to 10.04.2 LTS, I cannot recommend 11.04 to anyone and will not touch anyt Ubuntu newer than 10.10 ever. Ubuntu 11.04 has made it, I am done with Ubuntu after 10.04 will reach it’s end of life. My big thanks to Mark Shuttleworth for Unity, continue like this ( Wayland, Gnome 3 and more experimental unuseable stuff just made as ‘shinyness over usability’) and Ubuntu will be history by 2015.



Why Unity Will Become The Best Thing That Has Ever Happened To Ubuntu was originally published on Digitizor.com on July 4, 2011 - 3:38 am (Indian Standard Time)